In a letter addressed to the Board of Directors of the CSD, Ignacio Ridruejo, Cayetano Martínez de Irujo and Patxi Jiménez warn that the electoral call includes the provisional census of sports clubs, which is a document whose preparation stems from a series of agreements that are null and void, and which also violate the principle of legality and the principle of legal certainty.
They believe that the RFHE president's personal commitment has been exposed by adopting agreements despite knowing them to be illegal, since the report from the Broseta law firm, hired by the RFHE, already warned that the electoral regulations could not be modified by altering the census, and after four attempts to communicate with the CSD and the TAD, which he made unilaterally and behind the backs of all the federation's bodies, as has been made public in a statement posted on the RFHE's social media. (Written between March 1, 2024, and the end of May 2024.)
These are the reasons why it is requested that the actions be rolled back to the moment of the approval of the initial census, from which the agreements that are null and void began to be adopted, invalidating any subsequent act.
Document submitted to the CSD
expose
FIRST. – That on August 19, 2024, a document was submitted to the President of the CSD for referral to the Board of Directors requesting the precautionary and provisional suspension of the president and other members of the governing bodies of the RFHE, in accordance with the provisions of article 6.6 d) of Royal Decree 460/2015, of June 5, which approves the Statute of the Higher Sports Council.
SECOND. – In that same document, we denounce and warn, with respect to the complainant who is part of the RFHE delegated Commission representing the Navarra Equestrian Federation, that the principle of legality and the principle of legal certainty protected by the CE have been systematically and permanently violated, since in the meetings of the RFHE delegated Commission it has become customary -during this last year- not to allow the deliberation and debate of the items on the agenda, as ordered by the RFHE statutes in their articles 26 and 31.
These events have been reported to the secretary of the RFHE, who replies that the statutes protect this procedure, which is absolutely unconstitutional in our opinion.
THIRD. – It was also brought to the attention of this body to which we are addressing the fact that the RFHE delegated commission has reiterated, on June 13, 2024 and August 16, 2024, the non-compliance with the following regulatory precepts:
- Failure to comply with the provisions of article 14.g) of Law 39/2022, of December 30, on Sport, which establishes that it is the responsibility of the CSD to ratify the statutes and regulations of the Spanish sports federations, as well as their modifications.
- Non-compliance with article 12.3 of Royal Decree 1835/1991, of December 20, on Spanish sports federations and with article 6.6.b) of Royal Decree 460/2015, of June 5, which approves the Statute of the CSD, which empowers the Board of Directors of the CSD for the approval, ratification and modification of the statutes and regulations of the Spanish sports federations.
- Non-compliance with Order EFD 42/2024, which establishes in its article 4 the procedure for approval of the Electoral Regulations.
FOURTH. – Notwithstanding all of the above, on August 27, 2024, the elections for members of the general assembly, president and delegate commission of the RFHE have been called.
In said call, the provisional census of sports clubs is attached, a census which we consider NULL AND VOID in view of what was denounced in the letter dated August 19 submitted to the CSD.
In light of the foregoing, we hereby request the annulment of the call for elections to the General Assembly, President, and Delegate Commission of the RFHE, as well as the reinstatement of the suspension of the President of the RFHE. All of this is based on the following:
the following reasons.
REASONS
FIRST. – In order to delimit the procedure that is null and void, in successive agreements of the delegated commission of the RFHE, we must go back to the moment when allegations are presented to the initial census, published in accordance with ANNEX II of the Electoral Regulations.
(We attach as document no. 2 the initial census, and as document no. 3 the provisional census, published yesterday, which shows the alteration of the content of ANNEX II of the Electoral Regulations by eliminating more than 100 galloping clubs).
SECOND. – In order to resolve the objections to the initial census, on May 31st the president of the RFHE convened a delegated committee. In his powers as president, he decided to commission two legal reports – the exact nature of which is unknown – from the law firms Broseta and Sportia-law.
(We attach as document no. 4 the information note informing of the convening of the delegated committee on June 13, as well as the justification for the commissioning of the legal reports).
The communication literally stated: “Considering that the resolution of appeals to the initial census must be made by “the corresponding sports federation”, and in order to have the most appropriate criterion, the RFHE has requested legal reports from external and independent firms specializing in sports law on the content of these appeals.”
Despite the fact that one of the reports, that of the professional firm Broseta, clearly warned that the electoral regulations could not be altered indirectly through the resolution of allegations, the delegated commission approved the acceptance of the allegations relating to the galloping clubs, in a clear interference in the powers of the CSD, since said acceptance alters -de facto- the content of ANNEX II of the Electoral Regulations.
(We attach Broseta's opinion as document no. 5, although we extract the specific point in which they explain the impossibility of altering the regulations indirectly through the resolution of claims to the census).
The wording leaves no room for doubt, despite which, on June 13, 2024 and August 16, 2024, allegations to the initial electoral census were considered, the content of which directly affected the alteration of the provisions in ANNEX II of the electoral regulations approved by the Board of Directors of the CSD.
It is evident, therefore, that the approval of those agreements was made with knowledge of their illegality, as well as the fact that there is a recent Supreme Court ruling that establishes the jurisprudential criterion of the Administrative Litigation Chamber.
However, we refer to the legal basis in the THIRD section of this document, which was sent by registered mail on August 13 to the members of the delegated committee and which was invoked before the CSD in our letter dated August 19, 2024.
After that document became known, the RFHE made public a statement on its social networks -on August 20, 2024- in which it was revealed that the president of the RFHE had sent up to 4 statements -from March 1 to May- whose content we do not know because it has not been published on the RFHE website, has not been the subject of any information note, nor have they been made known to the delegated commission of the RFHE.
What is clear from the wording of this note is that the president of the RFHE has taken the exclusion of the galloping clubs as a personal matter and has put all the federative means into action to achieve this goal - even at the cost of having a presumably criminal attitude, without prejudice to the clear disciplinary responsibilities that he must assume.
THIRD. – THE EFFECTS OF THE NULLITY BY OPERATION OF LAW OF THE PROVISIONAL CENSUS ATTACHED TO THE CALL FOR ELECTIONS IN THE RFHE. NULL AGREEMENTS ADOPTED IN FRAUD OF LAW.
In view of the criteria of the Court established in the Judgment of the Administrative Chamber of the Supreme Court, dated April 15, 2024 (which will be very familiar to the president of the RFHE), we must determine two issues:
A) The activity we are denouncing, carried out within the federative sphere, is irregular; we refer to what is indicated in the report of the Broseta law firm in relation to this Judgment.
b)" (…) Seventh. Court's Judgment.
6. While federation regulations are not substantively administrative regulations or general provisions of that nature, their drafting and approval are not procedurally subject to the rules for drafting general provisions set forth in Articles 128 et seq. of Law 39/2015. Instead, they are drafted according to the statutes of each sports federation. Therefore, considering the private nature of sports federations and their self-regulatory capacity, in relation to the competence of the CSD, The approval of federation regulations follows a two-phase procedure: an internal, private legal phase of drafting and federation approvaland an administrative phase in which the CSD, exercising its supervisory authority, approves not a draft, but the regulations already approved by the federation. This distinction is relevant because, as we will explain below, the CSD cannot amend or revise what would be a draft; its oversight is limited to approving or rejecting the regulations and, if rejected, returning them to the sports federation.
We consider that the assessment of the allegations to the initial census, irregularly altering ANNEX II of the Electoral Regulations, are -within that two-phase procedure referred to in the aforementioned STS- subject to private legal regulations, since only what is administrative in nature has an administrative character: the resolution of the CSD that ends the administrative phase of the approval procedure.
However, in the case at hand, despite the fact that the administrative phase of approval of the Regulation was already definitive and firm, in an evident fraud of law, with an evident nullity of the agreements adopted, the delegated commission of the RFHE has arrogated to itself functions proper to the CSD, substantially altering the Electoral Regulation in its ANNEX II by eliminating the more than 100 galloping clubs.
In view of the above, since this is a situation that we consider borderline in terms of the legal nature of the agreements of the RFHE delegated commission of June 13, 2024 and August 16, 2024, we invoke Article 6 of the Civil Code - regarding absolute nullity and fraud of law and, subsidiarily, Article 47 of the LPACAP regarding acts issued by a manifestly incompetent body, and those issued disregarding the legally established procedure in total and absolutely.
In any case, without prejudice to the legal nature of the void preparatory acts, the fact is that there is an administrative act calling for elections, to which the administrative regulations apply, as can be concluded from the content and development of Order EFD 42/2024, which includes in its content the provisional census that is null and void and altered in fraud of law by the delegated commission of the RFHE.
In conclusion, we consider that the nullity of the provisional census is evident and more than proven, since it contravenes the provisions of the Sports Law, the Royal Decree on sports federations in Spain, the Royal Decree regulating the Statute of the Higher Sports Council and the provisions of Order EFD 42/2024 regulating electoral processes in sports federations in Spain.
In light of the above, we hereby REQUEST :
In accordance with Article 47.1 a) of the LPACAP, the NULLITY OF THE CALL FOR ELECTIONS TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, PRESIDENT AND DELEGATED COMMISSION OF THE RFHE, as it includes in it an essential document for the electoral process, which is the provisional census of sports clubs, which has been issued in fraud of law and, as we have demonstrated in the body of this document, violates the principle of legality and the principle of legal certainty regulated in Article 9 of the CE.
We also wish to reiterate our request submitted to the CSD in our letter dated August 19, 2024, because we have once again demonstrated that the conduct of the RFHE president is legally reprehensible.
In Madrid on August 28, 2024.
Signed, Francisco Javier Jiménez Huarte
Signed, Don Cayetano Luis Martínez de Irujo y Fitz-James Stuart
Signed, Mr. Ignacio Ridruejo Timbal










